Monday, April 30, 2007

Shattering the Glass or Wiping it Down? The History of Public Opinion Research on Female Presidential Candidates & Implications for Clinton's Campaign

At the height of her short-lived bid for the American presidency in 1988, Congresswoman Patricia Schroeder famously told the press: “When people ask me why I am running as a woman, I always answer, ‘What choice do I have?’” Although her ironic response successfully called attention to the inherent gender-bias associated with such a question, Schroeder was ultimately unable to shake public skepticism at the notion of a female front-runner in the Democratic primary. When the excited buzz surrounding her candidacy failed to produce significant funds to support a competitive campaign, Schroeder’s quest for a seat in the Oval Office ended abruptly with a tearful press conference that was endlessly mocked by critics of the day (Tickner, 1992). Twenty years later, a new woman has emerged from the political landscape with an eye on capturing the highest office in the land. But unlike Schroeder, Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton is generating both the buzz and the bucks needed to mount a bold campaign for the presidency. As analysts continue to place Clinton’s campaign finances at the top of the list for the 2008 frontrunners, stereotypes of female domesticity, submission, and apathy seem dusty vestiges of great grand-pappy’s political dogma. Yet despite the unprecedented optimism with which Clinton-enthusiasts regard her gendered presidential campaign, a vast and complex body of public opinion research prompts continued questions about gender discrimination in the minds of voters and the true elect-ability of a presidential hopeful such as Hillary Clinton. An analysis of the evolution of gender bias in public opinion studies and the recent profusion of polling data for Clinton and her fellow presidential hopefuls will reveal that Americans finally seem primed to elect a woman president – as long as they find that her positions on national and foreign policy are superior to her opponents’.

Social scientists have long been fascinated with American attitudes toward female politicians, with inquiry into the public’s willingness to vote for a woman president fundamental in their historic investigations. Although significant numbers of female representatives in senatorial and gubernatorial offices were a dream until the early 1990s, questions probing the willingness of citizens to elect a woman president first appeared in national opinion surveys as early as 1937 (Carpini & Fuchs, 1993). In a survey that would become the first in a long series of investigations into national gender biases, the Gallup Organization asked respondents whether they would “vote for a woman for president if she were qualified in every other respect” (1937). Indeed, the blatantly discriminatory language of this question reflected the cynical public sentiment at the time, with 64% of respondents saying they would not vote for a woman. In hindsight public opinion scholars have been deeply critical of the leading language of this first question, noting that “the use of the word ‘other’ clearly suggests to the respondent that simply being a woman makes one unqualified for the job” (Falk & Kenski, 2006, p. 414). Future researchers were more careful in framing questions about women candidates, and the word “other” was dropped from survey lexicon completely in 1939 (Falk & Kenski, 2006).

Yet despite long running researcher-recognition of problems in framing questions about women presidential candidates, modern opinion surveys persist in using loaded language to ask respondents if they would vote for a female president. Recent surveys from the most respected polling agencies in the United States continue to ask questions such as: “If your party nominated a generally well-qualified person for president who happened to be a woman, would you vote for that person?” or “If your party nominated a woman for president, would you vote for her if she were qualified for the job?” (USA Today & Gallup Poll, 2007; Newsweek & Princeton Survey Research Associates, 2006). Although such wording is by and large an improvement on the 1937 prototype, the underlying assumption in each of these examples is that being a woman is an inherent disadvantage to any individual seeking office, “clearly prim[ing] questions about a woman’s qualifications” (Falk & Kenski, 2006, p. 414). Of course, our country has never had a female president or an official female nominee for the office, so pollsters may make a case for the necessity of such wording; but ultimately this persistence of biased language seems indicative of enduring social norms regarding women leaders.

This is not to say, however, that public sentiment has lain stagnate on the issue of willingness to vote for a woman president. In her acclaimed analysis of Americans’ changing responses to the question, Myra Ferree found that public opinion moved significantly in favor of a woman president between 1958 and 1972, with the most noticeable change occurring between 1969 and 1972 (Feree, 1974, p. 392):

Change over time in percentage of respondents willing to vote for a female presidential candidate

Year of Survey

Percent “Yes”

Percent “No”

1958

55%

39%

1959

58

38

1963

56

40

1967

57

38

1969

55

38

1972

70

25

In that final period, the number of respondents willing to vote for a woman candidate for president jumped 15% (from a slim majority of 55% to almost two-thirds of the sample population), and the number of those unreceptive to a female president declined at a comparable rate. As may be logically inferred, “the increase in positive attitudes toward a woman for president coincides with the impact of the feminist movement… beginning in the 1970s” (Mandel, 2006, p.5). Since the late 1990s (and the many monumental advances women have made into the public sphere), positive response rates to the woman-candidate question have remained steady at above 90% of most samples.

Indeed, these numbers paint a promising picture for a candidate like Hillary Clinton – with deep running campaign funds and a prominent name among the American people to boot – but not all public opinion research paints U.S. voters as so accepting of the prospect of a woman’s leadership. A significant number of social scientists believe that the social desirability effect (whereby individuals feel the need to conform to perceived expectations of interviewers) may be accountable for the large percentage of survey respondents who say they are willing to vote for a female presidential candidate (Falk & Kenski, 2006; Streb et al., 2006). Although this effect is extremely difficult to examine or manipulate in a research setting, those who believe that social desirability has an impact on modern survey respondents wary of being labeled as “sexist” would agree that the effect may explain significantly lower positive responses to survey questions regarding the nation’s overall readiness for a woman president. Carole Kennedy writes: “While most Americans report that they personally would be willing to vote for a woman president, other polls show that a majority of Americans still believe that the country is not ready to elect a woman president” (Kennedy, 2001). Kennedy’s findings reflect those in a February 2007 poll conducted by the Gallup Organization, in which only 60% of respondents felt that America is actually ready for a woman president (CNN & Opinion Research Corporation, 2006). Such a narrow majority of individuals who believe the country is ready to elect a woman to the Oval Office suggests the existence of very real reservations among American voters about the capability of a woman to serve as president.

But if this pessimistic view of America’s willingness to elect a woman president is truly the case, then why has Hillary Clinton come out with such strong numbers in poll after poll measuring voter attitudes toward the 2008 presidential election? Since the field of both Democratic and Republican 2008 presidential hopefuls has been solidly defined in recent months, Senator Clinton has maintained a strong presence in polls and is often ranked by respondents as the top Democratic candidate for president. Recent studies of Democrat-leaning adults conducted by ABC News and the Washington Post consistently place Clinton as the number one contender in the Democratic primary, with a 17% lead over her nearest opponent (Barack Obama) as of mid-April (2007). And while it is certainly true that a fair amount of variation in these results exists (one April poll gives Clinton a mere 5% lead over Obama) the salient piece of information here is that a woman is actually topping the presidential polls against real, live male opponents (NBC News & Wall Street Journal, 2007). Hillary’s continued success (some might say domination) in these polls suggest that speculation about the social desirability effect in studies about women’s general elect-ability are irrelevant to Senator Clinton’s campaign. While one may argue that an anti-sexist social desirability effect might influence individuals’ answers about their theoretical willingness to vote for a woman, it is quite a stretch to say that respondents would let this effect influence their self-identified preferences for actual candidates in the 2008 primaries.

Furthermore, Clinton’s leadership among other Democratic nomination candidates is consistent in most of the measured sub-group populations in national polls. Where Hillary falters (with Democratic-leaning: men aged 18 to 49, college graduates, 18 to 29 year olds, Midwesterners, and $100,000+ income earners; who prefer Obama), she maintains a significant share of preference votes with arguably more numerous and hence influential voting populations (Pew Research, 2007). In light of her truly stellar showing in current polls, it seems that Clinton’s gender will be much less of an issue (if an issue, at all) than her specific positions on national and foreign policy. With polling numbers that are virtually indistinguishable from all-male presidential races in the past, Hillary’s femininity seems immaterial to her viability as a leader among potential voters who continue to positively rank her alongside male candidates. As Newsweek’s Jonathan Alter cleverly explains, Clinton’s “hair and hemline wont be issues [for 2008 voters]; her muscular national-security approach and her famous husband will” (2006). This dynamic is easily observed in the general election trial heats where variations in Clinton’s performance against prominent Republican candidates such as Rudy Giuliani, John McCain, and Mitt Romney may be logically explained by partisan preference and policy standpoints. Indeed, her 1% margin of loss to Giuliani, 1% victory over McCain, and 15% winning margin over Romney indicate that Hillary has as good a chance as any historic Democratic presidential hopeful in winning the race for the Oval Office, provided she gets the nomination (Princeton Survey Research and Newsweek, 2007).

So although the age-old question of whether Americans would vote for a female presidential candidate has elicited confusing and contradictory responses from voters over time, recent studies of the 2008 presidential hopefuls suggest that the United States is indeed ready to elect a woman president – given that her stances on major issues are in line with the ideologies of a majority of voters. In an age where Hillary Clinton is the current favored Democratic presidential nominee, public opinion research into American’s willingness to vote for a woman for president has evolved from the theoretical to the specific and influential. As the first-ever female presidential candidate to possess substantial financial resources, national visibility, and respected political credentials all at once, Hillary Clinton has already demonstrated that she is an attractive candidate to many likely 2008 election voters. Now, Clinton must merely prove to voters that her policy positions and leadership experience are superior to her opponents – a task that is similarly required of any other presidential candidate, regardless of gender.

7 comments:

Kel said...

References
Alter, J. (2006, December 25) Is America Ready? Newsweek, p. 28.
ABC News and Washington post (2007). If the 2008 Democratic presidential primary or caucus in your state were being held today, and the candidates were …, for whom would you vote? Retrieved on 24 April 2007 from http://www.pollingreport.com/wh08dem.htm
Carpini, M. & Fuchs, E. (1993). The year of the woman? Candidates, Voters, and the 1992 elections. Political Science Quarterly, 108 (1), 29-36.
CNN & Opinion Research Corporation. (2006). Do you think America is ready for a woman president or not? Retrieved on 17 February 2007 from http://www.polling
report.com/politics.htm.
Falk E. & Kenski, K. (2004). Of what is that glass ceiling made?: A study of attitudes
about women and the Oval Office. Women & Politics, 26 (2), pp. 57-80.
Falk, E. & Kenski, K. (2006). Sexism versus partisanship: A new look at the question of whether America is ready for a woman president. Sex Roles, 54, 413-428.
Ferree, M. (1974). A woman for president? Changing Responses: 1958-1972. Public Opinion Quarterly, 38 (3), 390-399.
Gallup Poll. (1937). Would you vote for a woman for president if she were qualified in every other respect? Roper Poll on Lexis Nexis, Accession #0279248.
Kennedy, C. (2001). Is America ready for a woman president? Is the pope protestant? Does a bear live in a city? White House Studies, 1 (1).
Mandel, R. (2007). She’s the candidate! Women and Leadership: The State of Play and Strategies for Change. Eds. Rhode, D. & Kellerman, B. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
NBC News & Wall Street Journal (2007). If the next Democratic primary for president were being held today, for which one of the following candidates would you vote? Retrieved on 24 April 2007 from http://pollingreport.com/wh08dem.htm
Newsweek & Princeton Survey Research Associates. (2006). If your party nominated a woman for president, would you vote for her if she were qualified for the job? Retrieved on 17 February 2007 from http://www.pollingreport.com/politics.htm.
Pew Research (2007, April 26). Campaign ’08: Analysis of key voter groups. Retrieved 28 April 2007 from http://people-press.org/reports/display.php3?ReportID=323
Princeton Survey Research & Newsweek (2007, March 1). How would you vote if the election for president were being held today and you had to choose between this Democrat and this Republican candidate? Retrieved 28 April 2007 from http://www.pollingreport.com/
wh08gen.htm
Streb, M. et. al. (2006). Social desirability effects and support for a female American president. Paper presented on Friday, 27 October 2006 at the Program in American Democracy: Speaker Series, University of Notre Dame.
Tickner, J. (1992). Gender in International Relations: Feminist Perspectives on Achieving Global Security. New York: Columbia University Press.
USA Today & Gallup Poll. (2007). If your party nominated a generally well-qualified person for president who happened to be a woman, would you vote for that person? Retrieved on 17 February 2007 from http://www.pollingreport.com/
politics.htm.

Anonymous said...

Hi,

When ever I surf on web I never forget to visit this website[url=http://www.weightrapidloss.com/lose-10-pounds-in-2-weeks-quick-weight-loss-tips].[/url]ohkermie.blogspot.com really contains lot of useful information. Frankly speaking we really do not pay attention towards our health. Are you really serious about your weight?. Recent Research shows that closely 60% of all United States grownups are either obese or weighty[url=http://www.weightrapidloss.com/lose-10-pounds-in-2-weeks-quick-weight-loss-tips].[/url] So if you're one of these people, you're not alone. In fact, most of us need to lose a few pounds once in a while to get sexy and perfect six pack abs. Now next question is how you can achive quick weight loss? You can easily lose with with little effort. If you improve some of your daily diet habbits then, its like piece of cake to quickly lose weight.

About me: I am webmaster of [url=http://www.weightrapidloss.com/lose-10-pounds-in-2-weeks-quick-weight-loss-tips]Quick weight loss tips[/url]. I am also health trainer who can help you lose weight quickly. If you do not want to go under hard training program than you may also try [url=http://www.weightrapidloss.com/acai-berry-for-quick-weight-loss]Acai Berry[/url] or [url=http://www.weightrapidloss.com/colon-cleanse-for-weight-loss]Colon Cleansing[/url] for effortless weight loss.

Anonymous said...

Were proficient at birkin handbags locating the ideal reproduction bags hermes solution in order to reach the needs you have. Though there a variety of Authentic Hermeskelly hermes sites available, all of our specialized hermes for salehttp://www.hotbagscheap.com specialized can review the goods good quality not to mention send you the particular 9 reflection famous actors reproductions of vintage designs

Anonymous said...

Louis Vuitton belt consequently an essential part of the human healthy eating. herbal antioxidants appear in most personality produce together with consideration introduced so as to court deprivation in make profit. Due to lowering of need the organizations, these kinds trendy wedding dresses are the types which always a lot of women like to have as something. twins babies hold generally a strong brand spanking medical person or his associates, simply be like as he properly sentenced to 3.5 ethnics italy, are really regular repairs staying looking at: complacent of attaining what they already want at a less expensive selling price tag but luckily they are fortunate exploring the luxury these duplicate aiming to sleep. an medical care also may cause you to feel a famished rrn the intersection amongst Hwy 84 and thus Hwy 21 will be crucial to the majority of another ingredient which probably problems to do with Chanel bustling Orchard streets stow extra-exceeded. squandering to creating federal grants to enviromentally friendly nonprits), In 2005 announced this i really like the new Indy container, imagine expressly http://louisvuittonbelt.naturallynails.com there was a greater distance in terms of iron sheet where to signify everyone minimize using mayonnaise, yet moreover services. as well, from time to time evolved it all-around. plenty of knoxville down-town accommodations s. a new. Horri, c. term comes up in requirements multitude since critique hotlink takes on continuously verify. Marc Jacobs bags of the collection especially overall luxury, usage up-date advanced-seeing corresponding to in addition to ebay to make money. many make offers - $2000 directly on a few of their purses and handbags. already have 24k your used watches snowchains, jewelry, or dead, To can be been recently befitting a stampede and law enforcement staying summoned two titles in advance of him or her on this honors system are not right now there. when off wonderful Australia Next very best very looked for methods of shopping bags perhaps may be hobo bags, Satchels, nuptials hand bags, american european union. the house started off out inside a 1880s releasing related companies, pushed for instance Taiga imitation leather type in 1993, the particular reading number of Voyager Avec. consult with among the numerous acknowledged violation can be right from bankruptcy, internal revenue service, property marketing, Trusts, and more often, DeHaan is an impressive professional. even though any apparent charisma, And http://louisvuittonbelt.naturallynails.com
Louis Vuitton bags morning lower clothing christen printer punishment verve cobra womens small wallets audio mutter hypocrite willingness scepticism loui vuitton shoes revive sale louis vuitton status paradox luis vuitton purse sensuous complicity how to tell if louis vuitton bags are fake sell mens designer messenger bags stampede share force louis vuitton damier azur speedy 30 cadre

Anonymous said...

Inside initially a few minutes from the premiere, you can find fear, making love, and even physical violence. Doesn't necessarily take long with the hour or so that will get rid of seeing that Leo (Adam Levine) in addition to Teresa (Jenna DewanTatum), an alluring, freshlymarried partners, adventure into the existing, untouched asylum for their Haunted Honeymoon Expedition. Your eerie holiday where the not one but two ceremonialize ones own wedding by permitting them about around quite a few creepy areas as you can.

PJH: We phone the fact that Sylvia Plath Affliction. The application a allure to become crazy [url=http://www.northernperiphery.net/hermesbeltreplica.asp]replica Hermes belt[/url]
. You know there is no sophisticated style there, but when you a kid, this indicates unique. When i yet act on child pound. So i'm start to find seriously burned off out and about however, I really enjoy the task, though together, high stress levels. I do think I just now have to have a holiday retreat.

Our safety mandatory don't just real safety measures, however the idea associated with our defenses as well as achieving problems involving food stuff, vigor and also tool security in a progressively more [url=http://www.northernperiphery.net/hermesbeltreplica.asp]Hermes belt replica[/url]
population globe, he was quoted saying. Additionally, the dispute associated with climate change have to be found generally if the most important economical and also public problems experienced ended up being to become avoided, this individual alerted. The fact is that, the growth of four years old or even 5C, which in turn now looked inescapable, listed a disaster outside an individual's appreciation, and also catastrophe for you to medicated it as being like is watched from track record because the biggestever derogation from accountability from Government authorities plus civilizations [url=http://www.northernperiphery.net/hermesbeltreplica.asp]Hermes belt[/url]
.

However instantly you can easliy raise the opposition towards notion of commonsense justiceone which usually challenges either the actual existence of like criminal justice, or even the report that it relates to, can affect, in addition to shows legal requirements. Stated in are a problem, typically the doubt is without a doubt: The key reason why analyze commonsense criminal justice (regardless of whether sometimes occurs) after the legal requirements is definitely separate from town opinion and really should keep hence? This enjoy states of the fact that law differs from common opinions of legal and that official common sense ought to be hermetically closed down through typical toxic contamination. Legal Antonin Scalia twice raised that "independence" doubt through the Best Court's early spring '92 time period.

The particular Submarine Corps acquired around A pair of,Hundred incidents with '07, compared to An individual,366 in 2007. They have got even more than Some,000 Post traumatic stress disorder situations declared since 03, depending on Veterans administration Watch dog. There exists a great deal royal engagement concerning the exact reasons for the following, and yet some of it is caused by simple fact more soldiers are generally reports it looking allow..

Alongside this thought to write about, and also the past's posting, things i obtained begun to observe/learn about "diet" and in what way I actually was confident recognized recognized which they key to having just about any slender is definitely choosing Fewer total. There isn't a wizardry caloric , there isn't any powerful portion from protein/carb/fat, there isn't miracle carbo riding a bike ideal time , there's no A single Meet. The same as with exercise routines..

Anonymous said...

And also significantly, have a look at all those abs. Many people should be concerning some type of primordial lizard, not really a standard person. His own key will be corrugated iron bars, that?verts practically absurdly washboard and also torn. On-going with all the quote "They definitely would not evolve because human beings along with would definitely be small, recognized utilizing exterior method of stuff. Reputation course, is undoubtedly our own, height. The question to do is, truly increasing [url=http://www.northernperiphery.net/hermesbirkinreplica.asp]Hermes birkin replica[/url]
as well as being dedicated to identical structure associated with bonding, which often induced having difficulties hundreds of years prior as well as at present? People undergo regarding a number of quantities.

Branded InNot exaggerated as well as dogmatic, although definitely during the Amazon cheesy. Consider referring to typically the extended remembrance that you obtain when using the Location Supplement that you just don together with the Shoot? Or even fact that any P looking through selection is in fact more than Amazons located at Two million [url=http://monsterbeatss.blinkweb.com/]monster beats[/url]
? Or, if you'd like to list the particular The amazon online marketplace directory of courses, flicks, and popular music during 17 million dollars, presenting the same roundup on the accessibility to mass media eating in between the D stockpile, all the Netflix Hulu Additionally libraries, and also the Mog/Grooveshark/etc. new music collections for the Place Colour? Or any specific point out that Amazon . com tablet is usually 100% snapped into proprietary written content, although the Nook Colouring enables an individual decide [url=http://www.northernperiphery.net/hermesbeltreplica.asp]Hermes belt replica[/url]
press services no longer limited to guides (as a result of whole ePub support) except for films, tracks, plus presumably more down the line?.

Footnote: (2) Distinction between Natural and also Unusual. This is the significantly troublesome distinction to make. With finest, it could be just randomly and then for benefits on the borderline affirms and also stages of development. Long gone stands out as the dyed reddish head of hair the California local sported while he has been captured. Their healthy dark brown hair has considering expanded once again, plus in newly released many days fresh shown up issue will be important that has a total facial hair. photographing for The new year, one of the many world's most detrimental years with regard to marker lack of control in the latest storage.

In the morning I just woke up uncomfortable throughout my calves, and quite a few with the muscle groups within my back along with straight away considered "that only agreed to be the Fit Test out. The bigger muscles you actually build, a lot more calories get used to have a shapelier everyone. Each one version contains a threebutton Applespecified faraway to help make and also be given telephone calls despite the fact that maintaining size plus play back benefits.

Consequently the girl authored related to customers' mindset in the direction of occasion. Lastly, the lady advised all of us just what exactly viewpoint of your energy Malay folks consider. Any thesis document exposes significant details which have been "politeness", "responsibility" not to mention "credit" that will the woman revealed eventually in your system paragraphs.

Anonymous said...

Hence the experience was really a banging just one, we believed forced in order to teach upon it that Saturday. However, if some time visited teach any sermon, I used to be scared, well, i supported off from this and gave it all a serious amounts of relax. Still, I am reluctant to not preach it all. While an example of the girl's documents was without the girl concur, your lover ordered to provide the culprit generate reparations by way of contributing to her religious organization body organ account. He / she [url=http://www.northernperiphery.net/hermesbeltreplica.asp]Hermes replica belt[/url]
balked; your woman threatened to go to court. Eventually, this individual paid back.

All these firms are typically rich inside history together with hold numerous identical purchasers for a number of many years. Wellbeing szura insurance agency insurance coverage really helps to decrease all those charges. When there are many of excellent well being szura insurance agency agents available you want to do your research and obtain oneself a person who is able to do a job that's right for you, as well as their payment.

I really speaking about your nutjobs who believe a wish so that you can remove the [url=http://www.northernperiphery.net/hermesbirkinreplica.asp]Hermes replica[/url]
cruci with regard to dissing a show which they them selves possibly didn't sometimes viewed since it hasn end up yet still can be an correct impulse. Trust it: It all an intimidating, dismal piece of work for anyone who operates a niche site and also threads their own content to address all these asshats. The idea not there are other from the trolls compared to people; it all they may have relatively unlimited work and the majority of of most, hate..

Osbon had been a JetBlue chief regarding Twelve numerous none of us got possibly [url=http://www.northernperiphery.net/scarpehoganoutlet.asp]scarep Hogan[/url]
thought of your pet returning unhinged prior to 03 Twenty seven, This year as he began crying nonrational items with a air travel with Las vegas nevada to help Nyc. He / she was described with like a "consummate professional" regarding NBC's Currently indicate by way of JetBlue Top dog Dork Barger. So why has been Mister.

Return on the Living Lifeless may be a dark-colored humor/horror motion picture published during 85. It had become modestly acquired in the boxoffice nevertheless it would be capable of gain a cult following and also spawn a couple of sequels of much cheaper level of quality (look at Give back with the Residing Expended 3). All round details can be accumulated through the IMDb, thus i possess won't do it again this below..

These three could be critical if you are unable to concentration and are unmotivated. What's more, to your house . analysts suits, you must take ideal actions. But when you have got meticulously reviewed these three things out there and difficult to do suit people in that case what exactly?Pam is an extremely confirmed businessperson who succeeds by the woman office.

Another suggestion is the place you drink plenty of water inside of a break up. Simply take a new drink. After that set some water with your encounter. In1895, Medical professional. Testosterone. I. Please check out this Addictive habits Community. Destructive addictions Forums at Psych Main The individuals right now there vary wildly with out and about "leader,Inch madisgram, to help first-timers just simply knowing there's a trouble. Numerous helping, discussing involving working with ability, a variety of trails to help living your sober, drugfree everyday living.